Let’s start with a disclaimer: there has been no official announcement from Amazon about the results of its year-long HQ2 search. Yesterday, the New York Times ran an article that sourced several people “familiar with the search” and reported that the online giant was in final negotiations to locate in both Queens, NY and the Crystal City section of Arlington, VA. The assumption is that Amazon will split its second HQ into two equal parts in those cities. Speculation about Crystal City arose over the weekend, prompting even Mayor Bill Peduto to make a statement that Pittsburgh had not been contacted by Amazon.
Amazon’s Seattle HQ
I think David Ruppersberger, president of the Pittsburgh Regional Alliance, got it right when he said that Pittsburgh won by making the short list. The effort to respond to the proposal taught Pittsburgh’s civic leaders even more about how to position the region and the public relations that have followed the city since has been valuable. Now we don’t have to deal with the mess that would have followed actually winning the project.
Pittsburgh’s tech sector is blossoming in multiple directions. Healthcare research is entering a potentially rapid expansion period. The energy sector holds great promise. And the petrochemical and plastics industries have yet to reveal what will happen when several ethane crackers open by the middle of the next decade. The regional economy is a good bet to create 50,000 new jobs over the next decade without having all of our eggs in one basket. Anyone remember how that worked out the last time Pittsburgh was reliant on one industry above all others?
Lots of interesting little private projects out to bid as the year winds down. In case you missed the BreakingNews email last week, Volpatt Construction was awarded the $6 million UPMC/IRMC Cancer Center at Indiana Hospital and Pitt chose PJ Dick for its Peterson Sports Complex field house expansion. Mistick Construction is taking bids on the $12 million development in New Kensington that will be the 47-unit Pioneer Apartments and offices for Wesley Family Services. Al. Neyer Inc. has started construction on three new industrial buildings: the third and fourth buildings at Clinton Commerce Park (268,000 square feet total) and a 50,000 square foot build-to-suit for Don’s Appliances at 251 Bilmar Drive.
Putting the November/December edition of BreakingGround into production this week and I was struck by how much of the commercial real estate sector was being driven by the universities and hospitals. I’ve been hearing so much about “eds and meds” that I was sick of hearing the phrase; but…it’s one of those things that you hear too much of because it’s a real thing.
Here are a couple examples of projects that have barely received any coverage but are happening because of the economic engines of CMU and Pitt. The URA recently approved the sals of land in the Pittsburgh Technology Center on Second Avenue to Elmhurst Group, which plans to build 160,000 square feet of “tech flex” space to attract advanced manufacturing, robotics or other technology spin-offs requiring research and maker space. Walnut Capital has received a lot of ink for its Bakery Square, JAA and PAA projects but the intriguing project is the Fifth and Halket property, which is reported to be an office building of several hundred thousand square feet. That property is in the opposite direction that much of the Oakland-driven development is looking but it will plant a flag on the more neglected Downtown side of Oakland, right by the Parkway East interchanges, right on the BRT route. If it becomes a major university or university-related corporate facility, it will be catalytic for the Uptown and South Oakland neighborhoods.
The universities are making construction news on their own. Duquesne announced the modernization of the Palumbo Center yesterday. The $45 million renovation will result in the rebranded UPMC/Cooper Field House. DRS Architects is designing the project, which should bid by early 2019 if the work is to start in the spring. CMU is proposing a new residence hall at Fifth and Clyde. LTL Architects was hired to design the $32 million project. CMU took CM proposals from Jendoco, Mosites and Rycon.
Rycon will do the construction of the AHN Brentwood micro hospital that had its groundbreaking recently. Work has not started yet. UPMC selected PJ Dick for its $15 million ED expansion at the UPMC East campus in Monroeville.
In other construction news, Franjo Construction was reported as the awarded general contractor for the $4.7 million Youghiogheny Administration Building for North Huntingdon Municipal Authority. Cast & Baker was the low bidder on the $4.5 million site prep package for the World Trade Center at the airport. That’s a project that could open up hundreds of millions in new commercial construction over the next decade, a project worth following.
The Urban Redevelopment Authority selected Lexington Partners – a joint venture of ICON Development and KBK Enterprises – to develop the Lexington Commons site in Point Breeze/South Homewood. The project will be a mix of 125 apartments (of which 50 will be affordable rentals) and 25 townhouses for sale. That’s similar to some of the developments KBK has done to replace Housing Authority of City of Pittsburgh projects in the Hill District. ICON is the development arm of Integrity Construction, owned by Jason Lardo. ICON’s vision for the commercial space includes renovation of more than 400,000 square feet of existing buildings into innovation space. The plan also involves extensive work to the infrastructure, including re-doing Thomas Boulevard and adding structured parking. The total development cost will exceed $110 million. The developer is working with Indovina & Associates. The site plan is below.
The $300 million-plus Esplanade development – a mix of residential, hotel, retail and waterfront construction on the North Side – being proposed by Millcraft Investments has gone to construction managers. Clark Construction, PJ Dick, Mascaro, Massaro and Rycon submitted proposals.
Pitt took CM-at risk proposals from PJ Dick, Mascaro, Massaro and Rycon on it $8-9 million Peterson Events Center vertical addition.
(Massaro was inadvertently omitted from the Esplanade and Peterson lists in the Oct. 11 email blast. If you don’t get the bi-weekly email blasts let me know.)
In other commercial real estate project news, Milhaus is taking proposals from Elford Construction, Franjo, PJ Dick and Rycon for the 2nd phase of its Arsenal multi-family development, which should be in the $40 million range. Developer T & R Properties from Columbus kicked of the construction of its $100 million Summit Station transit-oriented development in South Park with the start of the $30 million, 180-unit Summit Lofts.
When the Halloween decorations start showing up at Giant Eagle, the contracting season is usually wrapping up for the year. This year, however, there are a number of big projects on the street (and in the pipeline) that the market is making up for the lower number of projects with a much bigger dollar volume.
Part of this is the result of the lag from announcement to construction for some of the big projects that have been in the news over the past year or so. Mascaro took bids recently on the 410,000 square foot, $350 million UPMC Mercy Vision & Rehabilitation Hospital and the 96,000 square foot TCS Building at CMU. PJ Dick has been bidding the 300,000 square foot Bakery Square 3 office building.
Rendering of the new UPMC Mercy Vision & Rehabilitation Hospital by HOK. Image from UPMC.
There’s also been a flurry of activity on large projects at the early stages of development. Hanna Langholz Wilson Ellis is marketing the 1,200-acre Zediker Station site, which sits along I-70 just east of I-79. It’s the largest development site in PA and may be the only one served by both CSX and Norfolk Southern. The Hazelwood Green project has been advertised for developer proposals. Over the long haul, that’s a project that could lead to more than $1 billion in construction. The developer currently on site, RIDC, has reportedly locked up autonomous vehicle company Aptiv for 70,000 square feet to occupy most of the 2nd building in its Mill 19 project. That would trigger the start of the third 90,000 +/- square foot final phase. In the Strip District, Facebook confirmed that it was leasing most or all of District 15, a 105,000 square foot building being developed by RDC on Smallman Street. According to a recent story by Tim Schooley in the Business Times Facebook’s lease is the tip of the iceberg. Schooley quotes JLL’s Dan Adamski estimating that there are 900,000 square feet of user requirements being shopped in the Strip now. That would make for another explosion of office projects. One of those may be JMC Holdings’s proposed adaptation of the Wholey cold storage building on 15th Street. The developer has engaged Desmone Architects to work on a 350,000 square foot re-use but is reported to be looking at hiring an architect to design a new 17-story, 500,000 square foot building on the site.
As intriguing as this tech demand is, it’s worth noting that most, if not all, of it is new in 2018. It was only last year that occupants like Apple and Argo AI were snatching up big chunks of 3 Crossings. When someone says that the emerging technology sector is growing faster than you can understand, this is what they mean.
Thursday morning, URBN announced they were building an 863,000 square foot fulfillment center for Urban Outfitters at the Windy Ridge Business & Technology Park in Indiana, PA. The project is one of the few mass fulfillment centers located west of the I-81 corridor and is a tremendous return on the investment made by the Indiana County Center for Economic Operations (CEO).
Indiana County CEO executive director, Byron Stauffer, says that $20 million had been invested in the Windy Ridge project over a period of more than ten years. Stauffer was effusive in his praise for the governor, Senator Don White and Rep. Dave Reed for their support of the project, which attracted a variety of grants and loans. URBN said that the fact that Indiana County had a prepared site, available workforce (the facility will employ more than 200), access to Route 422 and the IUP supply chain management program, tipped the decision in favor of the Windy Ridge site.
“The lesson learned here is if you think small, you get small,” Stauffer concluded.
Blue Rock Construction from Allentown is the construction manager for the $60 million-plus facility, which will have 45-foot precast concrete panels on the exterior. Construction is scheduled to be completed by late summer 2019.
I got an interesting call yesterday from the local Federal Reserve Bank office asking about the impact of Hurricane Florence on the construction industry. They are trying to figure out the economic effect of the storm. The short answer is that it’s too early, of course, but history gives a little insight into the aftermath. Ike, Katrina and Harvey were similar storms in that they brought massive amounts of water damage. That means much of the damage is uninsured and more difficult to quantify. That also means that the rebuilding will likely stretch out over several years (or longer).
What is different now from 2017 or 2005 is the lack of capacity to rebuild. For building materials, supply is already limited for what will be in highest demand, like lumber, plywood, drywall, and construction equipment. That means there will be price increases, but, with little slack capacity, the availability will be a bigger factor. The same is true for labor. It will take tens of billions to rebuild and repair the flood damage but there will only be so much that can be rebuilt without skilled workers. The winter slowdown in northern cities might provide some labor force, but there is enough construction that there may not be many layoffs this winter. That will certainly be true of Pittsburgh’s construction workforce.
The guess here is that – like with Katrina – the reconstruction in the Carolinas will be stretched out over a number of years.
In project news the Builders Exchange reported on a project that the Turnpike Commission is requesting prequalification to bid. The Southern Beltway maintenance shops are budgeted in the $25 million range and based upon history should go out to bid in the month following the Oct. 24 prequalification due date.
Pittsburgh’s construction industry lost a great guy on Monday. Brian McKay passed away after battling ALS for the past year or so. Brian owned AMB Plumbing & Excavating and was incredibly involved in the industry, serving the Mechanical Contractors Association and the Builders Exchange for many years. He was past president of the MCA and the current president of the PBX board. Brian was a man who quietly helped a lot of people out over the years. He will be missed. Visitation will be held today and tomorrow at Schellhaas in Franklin Park. The details are in Brian’s obituary.
The bids taken Sept. 11 on Pitt’s $41 million Salk Hall Renovation Phase 2 had the hallmarks of growing inflation and a market that is busy. The $50,862,000 total for base bid #1 was about 25% over budget and the project will likely re-bid after scope changes, since there were few alternates to reduce the cost. Burchick was the low general contractor. The general bids are below:
I don’t have enough information to deduce how much inflation impacted the project but the U.S. index for inputs to construction rose 9.6%, 8.1% and 8.1% year-over-year in May-July. There are also some indications that the current market conditions played a factor. There were only 3 bids on the general and electrical packages. HVAC received 4 bids and plumbing received 5. That’s a dramatic difference from what a Pitt-delegated project would have received even one year ago. Moreover, the gap between bids was big. Burchick’s low bid was 6.8% below the second low bid, and 10.2% below the third. That was the tightest spread by far. The spread between the low and second bids on the other 3 contracts was at least 9.5% and as much as 12.5%.
One of the strong economic signs has been the upswing in owner-occupied industrial/manufacturing projects. Yesterday, Uwharrie Builders from NC broke ground on an 80,000 sq. ft. expansion for Technimark in Latrobe. On August 20, New-Belle Construction pulled a permit for a 68,000 sq. ft. new facility for Zilka & Company in Mason Park, an industrial park near New Stanton. Westmoreland County IDC has been preparing new pads in several locations in anticipation of opportunities like these. Zilka is in the bakery products business and Technimark does rigid plastic injection molding for healthcare applications. While emerging technologies and gas-related energy should drive growth in manufacturing, the gains in regional manufacturing seem to have a wider base.